breaking the wheel

A growing debate in the field asks whether marketing has been reduced to an activity and has lost its place as an academic discipline that spans the whole business. That it has morphed into a department that produces campaigns and its original purpose has become muddled and lost.

The argument remains unresolved, particularly in B2B, where academic research has historically lagged behind that of B2C and brand strategy. The general consensus seems to be that the discipline has done this to itself. Yet marketing as a topic is gaining traction in the B2B community. The pandemic, the rise of AI, a competitive job market and tightened budgets across the board mean that managing directors and CFOs, not just marketing heads, have to be able to track and justify its value.

When I started to unpack this, a quiet discontent grew around how the marketing function is understood and experienced day-to-day, both by those inside it and those working alongside it. So I went back to the foundational texts and I found that the models marketing has been on didn’t help as much as they should in today's market. The discipline settled decades ago on a set of categories, the four Ps among them, because they took a complicated subject and packaged it into something that could be more easily understood and managed. The approach was, and still is, foundational. But it creates tension with branding and creative delivery, and, set against them, can feel like a checklist that misses the point. McKinsey’s State of the Market 2026 report supports this, showing that branding remains a top concern for Europe-based leaders.


In recent years, models have expanded to include the now-infamous wheel and describing marketing as a system has become a common theme. The wheel has grown in popularity and for good reason: it reflects how marketing operates from the inside. Plan, iterate, measure, review, plan, iterate…round and round it goes.

The risk is that a wheel, or any marketing framework that looks good as a one-pager, cannot capture the real work that is required within a growing, specialist business. One-pagers reduce marketing to a delivery function and too often treat the strategic layer as the preserve of enterprise business, where capacity and resources can be addressed with budget. That assumption is part of the problem. Marketing has real faults as a standalone discipline. It is unwieldy and hard to justify. But if the research agrees on one thing, it is that it cannot be run from inside a single model or shape and that innovative thinking is usually the key to growth, not implementing a set of expensive tools or complicated processes.

The funnel gave way to the wheel, and the wheel will give way to what follows. Each model is useful, but for a business whose marketing has never quite delivered what was expected, the question is not which model to adopt next.

It is about whether the function has been built with intention, scale and alignment, with a focus on putting the customer at the centre. That is why training in strategic thinking holds true value. It cannot be commoditised, and the context on which the strategy is built cannot be modelled entirely by AI. In fact, investing time upstream of delivery is what makes the model of the moment, the latest tools and ultimately the customer positioning deliver real value.

Previous
Previous

B2B Tech Growth Architecture

Next
Next

Repositioning marketing